Starbucks’ Gift Card Playbook, Gen Z Gifting Trends, Fee-Free States

💡 Case Studies

How Starbucks Turns Coffee into Gold

You might think Starbucks is just hawking frappuccinos, but it’s quietly playing the gift card game like a master chess move. Here’s the deal: by training millions of caffeine devotees to load $20 onto prepaid cards, Starbucks consolidates six coffee purchases into one transaction—cutting credit card fees down by 83%. On their scale, those saved nickels translate into millions. Beyond fee savings, gift cards deliver cash flow upfront and encourage customers to overspend—75% of gift card users spend more than the card’s value. Even better? 10-19% of balances are never redeemed. That leftover latte money? Pure profit. Whether the cards sit in wallets like branded billboards or get swiped for six transactions’ worth of cold brews, Starbucks has built a gift card system that keeps customers spending and their margins smiling. 

Lesson learned: a small tweak in payment strategy can brew serious business gains.

🏛️ Legislation Corner

State fees

State laws regarding dormancy and service fees on gift cards vary significantly, reflecting an ongoing debate about consumer protection and fee transparency. Many states, including Connecticut, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Vermont, have adopted a strict approach by prohibiting fees altogether. These states prioritize protecting consumers from any potential value loss on gift cards, ensuring the full value remains intact regardless of inactivity or time elapsed. Certain states, such as Louisiana and Massachusetts, allow limited exceptions, such as a $1 handling fee or prohibiting fees only if they reduce the card's value.

Other states take a more flexible stance, allowing fees but requiring clear and conspicuous disclosure to ensure transparency for consumers. California stands out with specific conditions under which fees are allowed: fees are permitted only if the gift card's remaining balance is $5 or less, the fee is no more than $1 per month, the card has been inactive for 24 months, and it is reloadable. These nuanced approaches highlight the balance between protecting consumers and accommodating businesses while demonstrating the complexities of state-level gift card regulations.

📈 Seasonal Insights

Consumer habits by generation

The 2024 holiday season highlights a clear trend: gift cards remain a popular choice across all generations, with younger consumers leading the way. According to the data, 49% of Gen Z and 42% of Millennials were more likely to buy or give gift cards, significantly surpassing the overall average of 38%. This reflects the growing preference among younger generations for practical, flexible gifting options that allow recipients to choose exactly what they want. Meanwhile, Gen X and Baby Boomers lag behind, with 35% and 31% respectively, underscoring a generational divide in holiday shopping behavior. For Gen Z, in particular, gift cards align with their digital-first lifestyles, offering convenience and customization during the busiest shopping season of the year.

The findings emphasize that gift card providers have a prime opportunity to target younger generations during the holidays, where demand for versatile and hassle-free gifts is highest. Tailoring marketing campaigns to appeal to Gen Z and Millennials can drive engagement, especially through digital platforms where these groups are most active. Additionally, while Baby Boomers and Gen X may not embrace gift cards at the same level, they still represent a substantial market share worth addressing through promotions and bundled offerings. As gift card usage continues to rise, particularly among younger consumers, businesses that strategically position gift cards as the perfect holiday solution stand to capture significant seasonal spending.

📰 Interesting Articles